Jul 19

Are you a “working mom” or a “stay-at-home mom”?


Doin' It All

One of the things that struck me most about making the decision to return to work vs. staying at home was that there were so few options.  I could either a) return to work full-time or b) stay at home full-time.  There were no other options.  How is it that women have been in the workplace for decades now and typically we still have only two options in this regard?

A girlfriend of mine works for a company that offered her a part-time position upon returning from maternity leave.  She works Monday – Thursday from 8am – 1pm.  Therefore, she has every afternoon & all day on Friday to play with her daughter. This seems like the best of both worlds & I’ve heard her describe it as such.  But she is the only mom-friend I have who is working part-time.  Everyone else had a tough decision to make.

When I was making my choice I spoke with my company about what part-time options might be available.  Of course they would have to create a position for me because no one else in my company was doing this.  What they offered amounted to part-time hours with part-time pay but full-time responsibilities.  I would of course have a blackberry, have to attend sales conferences across country, have to work from the downtown office & be expected to perform at the same level as my full-time coworkers.  I started to imagine that if I chose that path I would be a full-time mom, part-time employee and feel like I was pulled in two directions; not accomplishing what I’d like in either area.

I chose to stay home & I’m generally happy with the decision.  When I head downtown & see women in their “dressed-up” business attire with the latest fashions I do get a pang of jealousy.  I remember working in an office surrounded by fun people, grabbing fro-yo with a coworker & even happy hour after a long day at meetings.  In those moments of memories, I forget the corporate bureaucracy, the “re-orgs”, cubicle nation & my limited vacation days.  Of course, if I truly wanted to get back there I could.  But I choose not to.  I don’t want to leave my daughter with someone else, not because of any effect it might have on her, but because I enjoy spending time with her, I enjoy our routine and my household “job” & I enjoy my easy life too much to alter it at this point.

I do believe though that one option is not inherently better than another; there is no definitive “best” for the child.  I know many would disagree with this opinion.  But I think whatever is best for the family, is best for the child.  I never expected to be a happy stay-at-home mom.  I thought I would go crazy and eagerly return to work.  I thought we’d get a nanny or send our daughter to daycare, like my mom did for me, and all would be copacetic.  If I had been miserable at home & longing to return to Corporate America I don’t see how staying-at-home would automatically be “best” for our child.

Since women are forced to choose 1 out of 2 options, it’s almost as if they separate in to camps.  Are you a “Stay-at-home Mom” or a “Working Mom”?   Once you answer that question, a divide is created.

And we can, at times, be so critical of each others decisions on how they raise their children, especially with this hot-button issue.  It’s almost as if another mom choosing to return to work when you chose to stay-at-home is a judgment against your decision or vice versa.

In my ideal world, we’d all recognize that what works for us, might not work for everyone.  Rather than foster a division, we’d support one another, seek connection & know that a loved baby is always the best, whether mom works outside the home or inside the home.



  • http://alittleyum.wordpress.com Simran Stacie

    I hear you in the pang of jealousy. Downtown does that to me as well. It helps to know we are not alone in how we feel. Great post. Thanks!